Frequently Asked Questions
about the Railroad Control Interface
Isn't the RCI similar to several other systems? Not
Really! RCI is the only system which provides complete support for
conventional (non-DCC) locomotives. It can also be a valuable addition to DCC-based
layouts, providing block detection, signaling, and control of turnouts and other
motorized devices. The RCI distributes functionality so the PC can do high level
management functions, while each RCI card handles the details and critical timing
functions. RCI provides a modular approach with a complete, integrated
family of products.
What does "complete support" mean? RCI is the
only system
that can provide computerized block throttles economically, allowing
implementation of a Computer Block Control system. CBC allows more trains
to be run, with greatly simplified wiring, and far fewer components than Cab
Relay systems. Other systems are designed primarily for turning outputs on and off,
but can only provide variable track power by adding expensive throttle cards
appended to output cards;
and adding block detection requires even more cards. With our CBC-8, you
get eight throttles and eight detectors on a single, compact card that's loaded
with features. Compare the total system cost of doing
computerized block control and detection with RCI, versus cab control (with
banks of relay cards) using other systems. You'll see that our CBC-based
system does much more for far less.
Why do you charge "extra" for providing assembled and tested
cards? More than 80% of our customers buy pre-assembled and tested cards,
and these cards are priced very competitively with other systems.
However, some railroaders would rather spend time than money, and many actually
enjoy building electronic kits. So we offer our system in kit form at a
discount for those who would prefer to build their own.
What if my kit doesn't work after I assemble it?
What about Warranty? This has actually happened, once, in the past three
years. Our policy has always been complete customer satisfaction. So we
will replace your kit immediately with a fully assembled and tested unit,
or provide replacement parts - your choice. And, we don't look at the calendar
if you return a card (kit or pre-assembled) for repair -- it's fixed at no cost,
regardless of how long you've owned it.
Why do your standard outputs only provide 0.15 amps versus 10
amps for some other systems? The choice of using electronic outputs rather
than relays provides a number of benefits: more functionality, lower power
consumption, and more compact circuitry. You can't do variable intensity
lighting, color mixing (for searchlight signals), or variable speed motor
control with relays. And try to imagine a card (like our O-48) with 48 relays
for output - it would be the size of a small chess board!
A majority of the powered items on the typical railroad (e.g.
signals, crossing flashers, stall-motor switch machines) draw less than 0.1 amp;
LEDs are 0.02 amps. For those few situations where you need higher power,
such as solenoid-operated turnouts, we offer modular, attachable solutions. And
- although you could run a train by just using a relay to start and stop it, do you
really want to? Control of trains requires throttles, and we offer several
excellent throttles for train control.
What can I do with an IO-48 or IO-24 without buying add-ons? Even
with our starter kits (IO-48 or IO-24 and RS-4 interface) alone, you can connect and use
all the following railroad items: Any type of signal, including searchlight,
stall-motor turnouts (e.g. Tortise) or any similar low-current motor, crossing
flashers, single lights (flashing, or on/off control), external 12-volt relays
to switch heavy loads, or any other electronic device that has compatible
inputs. Inputs can include simple contacts, such as switches and pushbuttons,
magnetic reed switches, photocells, infrared detectors, and pre-built block detectors
or optical detectors from any manufacturer.
How do I connect devices to your system? Our
IO-48 and O-48 have plug-in connectors which require that you crimp wires into terminals and insert them
into standard Molex housings. This was a request of many customers with medium
to large layouts. They wanted to be able to swap out a board if necessary,
without trying to unscrew 50 wires, and attempting to get them all reconnected
correctly. And, Molex terminals are compact, rugged, and widely available. We
actually offer the best of both worlds with our screw terminal converters
which allow the flexibility of screw terminals with the plug-in convenience of
Molex connectors. Since our newest cards, the CBC-8 and IO-24, have fewer
connections to make, we've simplified hookup by providing screw terminals right on
the cards. And we've recently added "flexi-connectors" which allow a choice of
three ways to do your wiring (direct soldering, crimp terminals, or screw
terminals) while adding built-in resistors for signals and turnout motors, AND
plug-in convenience!
Aren't there "hidden" costs for PC interface and add-on
boards? Our IO-48 starter package includes everything you need to get
started (see question above), including the PC interface, cable, output test card, and input test
card for only $170 (assembled). This starter package provides 16 inputs and 32
outputs, enough for a modest sized layout. We also offer an even
less expensive starter kit, featuring the IO-24 card. You will
need to add a power supply and a serial cable (available from any Radio Shack
store). As we have always stated, you need to examine the total system
cost for your entire layout, not just the cost of the first
small card. Our high-density circuitry provides the lowest cost for any layout
that needs more than a handful of input and outputs.
Why don't you provide control software for the PC to operate
your RCI cards? Railroad & Co.
software provides nearly everything on our "wish list" for a control system,
with more to come. We have packages available that include Railroad and
Co. at a great price. You will soon have the option of using our
very own Railroad Operator control system, which provides simplified setup and
operation, at no cost to purchasers of RCI hardware.
In addition, many
modelers want or need to develop custom software solutions for their railroads.
We support this effort with easy to use interfaces, extensive documentation, and
complete demo programs.
What kind of computer do I need to operate the RCI system?
Nearly any
computer capable of communicating through a serial port at 19200 or 38400 baud can be
used to operate the RCI network. This includes Windows, DOS, or even Linux-based
PCs. Newer systems without a serial port will require an USB to serial
converter.
Can't I do everything with my DCC system? Yes, and no.
While DCC systems are becoming more capable with the availability of stationary
decoders and input sensing, RCI often can provide block detection, signaling,
turnout control, and operation of other accessories at a lower cost per
function. A separate control system like RCI also reduces the workload on the
command station and the DCC communication network, resulting in better overall
system performance. Examine the capabilities of your DCC system very carefully
before deciding which way to go. A PC-based system like Railroad and Co. can
easily support multiple interfaces and coordinate activities between RCI and
your DCC system.
Is RCI reliable enough to control critical functions on my
railroad? The RCI system contains several features to ensure
ultra-reliable control. The RS-485 network used by RCI is inherently resistant
to electrical noise, even when using low cost cabling. Each message sent by the
controlling PC has a check byte embedded in it that is validated by the
receiving card. The card address and command code must also be valid, or the
message will not be acted on. Every message is positively acknowledged and will
be retransmitted if not acknowledged within a few milliseconds. Compare this to
other systems on the market, which just ASSUME that the data is being
transmitted correctly, and have no means of catching or correcting
transmission errors.
Inbound messages
from an RCI card to the PC are checked and validated in a similar manner. Also, each
card will automatically reset its communication interface if a partial or
garbled message
is received. And, each card has a watchdog timer that will reset the entire card
in the remote chance that a malfunction occurs. In an actual test we
performed, an RCI network was run for more than 48 hours - transmitting and receiving over
one hundred million messages - without a single error.
In addition, all RCI cards have an on-board filtered, regulated
5 volt power supply which provides rock-steady operating voltage for the card's
logic (especially important for microprocessors). Running 5 volt power
around a large layout, as is required by some other systems, invites noise
pickup and unreliable operation.